About the Author

mansoor here from lahore pakistan...luv muzik n SRK....

See All Posts by This Author

There Are 33 Responses So Far. »

1. 

   Comment by don on 7 November 2008:

   my point proved
   Comedy Sells not Comedy Stars.
2. 

   Comment by don on 7 November 2008:

   You will soon see the headlines.
   Tushar Kapoor asking 30 cr for a movie
3. 

   Comment by don on 7 November 2008:

   Though it could not beat the SIK record or OSO record but it has competition with Fashion.
   Where as the latter has none.
4. 

   Comment by Zahir on 7 November 2008:

   OSO had compition from Bhansali Saawariya.
5. 

   Comment by sandip on 7 November 2008:

   you are absolutely right don ……………
6. 

   Comment by Amit on 7 November 2008:

   What rubbish don, OSO or SIK was big only because of SRK and Akki, what are you talking? GR was a sequel thats why there was craze, and also diwali.
   Its stars who sell, not comedy
   Then why, Krazzy 4, One Two Three, God Tussi great Ho, Sunday, Mere Baap Pehle Aap didnt become hits don although very much hyped.
   Its not comedy which sells, its stars! Talk sense.
7. 

   Comment by Amit on 7 November 2008:

   But I could say ronadhona sells more than comedy because female audiences are immediately attracted to ronadhona genre, so it sales.
8. 

   Comment by Amit on 7 November 2008:

   Talk some sense!
   By the way, GR and OSO released in diwali, great advantage. SIK with more prints but in a ordinary day with 13 more films releasing in August with 3-4 every week.
9. 

   Comment by Rajeev on 7 November 2008:

   But..i am sure…Akki (The real King)cant even score 30 cr with a emotional romantic movie…

   without Comedy..akki is not the KINNG..
10. 

    Comment by Amit on 8 November 2008:

    SRK cant even score anything without non-ronadhona drama with few exceptions here and there
    Without ronadhona..srk is not the king Rajeev
    As i said, Ronadhona drama sells, not ronadhonadrama stars
11. 

    Comment by Rajeev on 8 November 2008:

    Amit..

    I have nothing to say on your comments..
12. 

    Comment by don on 8 November 2008:

    Amit
    cracking jokes is good but cracking bad jokes isn’t
    I think u missed most of the SRK movies.
    plus can AAMIR SALMAN AKKI sell this so called RONA-DHONA as per u?
13. 

    Comment by Fenil on 8 November 2008:

    42.2 cr is a gr8 collection, but I dont feel GR will break OSO’s record.

    FENIL
14. 

    Comment by Amit on 8 November 2008:

    I am not cracking jokes, you are don. i havent missed his movies
    Srk can sell ONLY ronadhona, and YA All these above mentioned can sell ronadhona and get in females’ heart easily but the difference is they dont do it more often as srk
    Now, your turn to answer me- can srk sell and DO daredevil stunts and sell action flicks(not talking abt crap action of the past like in don and don), can he carry off a good comedy( not desperado)? answer me
15. 

    Comment by don on 8 November 2008:

    hahaha
    are you done?
    Yes he can.
    Tell me any Rona Dhona film that really made a mark of the above mentioned stars.
16. 

    Comment by Ankur Bhai MBBS on 8 November 2008:

    well Don for Aamir it was Raja Hindustani lol and Hum hai Rahein Pyaar ke (rona dhona ) and for akshay WAQT and Salman Huma saath Saath Hai, Hum AApke hai Kaun , Maine Pyaar Kiya to name a few all dese movies had romance nd rona dhona and made der presence felt at Bo also… and ya Aamir QSQT the first Raj of Indian Cinema and DIl hehee and dil hai ki maanta nahi
17. 

    Comment by don on 8 November 2008:

    you mentioned all good films except HSSH and it was multi starrer.
    Hum Hain Rahi Pyaar Ke? felt cried? it was a cool movie! some scenes were there which u guys call Rona Dhona….
    Akshay did a great job no doubt in Waqt…but how many?
    Hum Aap Ke Hain Kaun? Family Drama Where was the crying part in mid and end. and it was a full family film.
    thats why people prefer RAJ of DDLJ to QSQT.
    Dil Hai Ki Manta nahi…only went sad in 3rd quarter[for some mins] go and find a plot which can be called RONA-DHONA
    and first see my perception in previous comments..
    i called it SO CALLED RONA-DHONA a/c to you guys. Its not RONA-DHONA ONLY for me
18. 

    Comment by Ankur Bhai MBBS on 8 November 2008:

    Don ppl Loved RAJ of QSQT also it became a Rage made Aamir an overnight star
19. 

    Comment by don on 8 November 2008:

    who is remembered today?
20. 

    Comment by prince on 8 November 2008:

    Amir has delivered only four hits since 2000.So please don’t discuss his star power here coz d figures are self explanatory.He can not deliver hits one after another like srk.Mark my word, his all star value ll be exposed in Ghajini(Amir khan ki aag).Actually he is damaging himself now by doing such kind of movies as being misfit for such roles.He has got limitations as an actor and one movie after two years is good thing for him.
21. 

    Comment by Amit on 8 November 2008:

    Prince, the way i see it its srk who has most limitations as an actor as is said he can only sell ronadhona
    Don didnt answer my question properly about deadly action flick and good comedy of srk
22. 

    Comment by Amit on 8 November 2008:

    By the way, each and every actor/director whose interview I have seen have said comedy is much more tough than putting glycerine and crying.
23. 

    Comment by Amit on 8 November 2008:

    And one more thing, SRK himself said in a magazine interview before the release of OSO- “Maae bhi chahta tha ki mera bhi salman, john, sunny ki tara body ho- ye loge trendsetters haae; maae pehle aur abhi bhi chahta hu ki sunny deol type ka role karu, mere bete ko aisa action role pasand haae lekin mujhse nahin hota, mere dost bhi kehte haae ki mujhe aisa role suit nahi karta” I am not making this, he exactly said this! He was honest but himself proving his limitations, so no point trying to defend him, ismt it DON?
24. 

    Comment by UKAP on 9 November 2008:

    You are spot on Amit, i also read it and he also said the same thing in TV.
25. 

    Comment by UKAP on 9 November 2008:

    Akshay Kumar is the Best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
26. 

    Comment by don on 9 November 2008:

    at least he accept things of others about body etc.
27. 

    Comment by Ankur Bhai MBBS on 9 November 2008:

    Even Aamir is remembered Don…ask Anybody… u just cant Ignore Aamir Don… He is D ACE of Bollywood …and Prince we will c Ghajini will be d Aamir khans aag or nt mark my words if its doesnt succeed at BO den i will stop praising him …
28. 

    Comment by Fenil on 9 November 2008:

    SRK himself said in an interview that “The territory of superstar doesn’t belong to one actor today” (check the full article: http://filmikhabar.com/2008/10/21/i-am-not-%e2%80%98king%e2%80%99-to-my-kids-shahrukh-khan/). So, SRK, Aamir, Akki-all r equal superstars.

    And Amit, wat ronadhona film of SRK r u talking about? Was OSO, Chak De, Don, Kal Ho Naa Ho, Badshah, Asoka, Mohabbatein ronadhona films? And actually, Aamir made every1 cry with TZP. Then wud u call Aamir a ronadhona actor and TZP a ronadhona film? This is just not done Amit.

    FENIL
29. 

    Comment by don on 9 November 2008:

    i am not ignroing him ankur but RAJ is only remembered as SRK today. Majority rules.i even do not remember AK character as RAJ though i loved that movie.

    @fenil
    well said bro.
30. 

    Comment by Amit on 10 November 2008:

    But Fenil, aamir doesnt do ronadhona often like srk.srk only does same thing nd is polar among girl audience
31. 

    Comment by Amit on 10 November 2008:

    well well don didnt answered and named one good comedy film and great action of srk
    singh is king and mithya are only clean hit comedies of this year don,others below avg or flop. looking at past, emotional drama sells the most bt not emotional drama stars
32. 

    Comment by fenilseta on 10 November 2008:

    Amit, at least mention the name of srk’s ronadhaona films
33. 

    Comment by don on 10 November 2008:

    i think my name speak about ACTION
    BADSHAH–BETTER COMEDY THAN MANY SO CALLED MARVELOUS COMEDIES
    DUPLICATE

Post a Response